7 Remote Work Policy Mistakes That Could Land You in Legal Trouble
Remote work transformed from an occasional perk to a business necessity almost overnight. While many companies rushed to implement remote work...
7 min read
When Jennifer Martinez thought she was handling a routine employee termination at her growing software company, she had no idea that one overlooked detail in the severance package would cost her business $2.3 million and nearly destroy her company's reputation. The mistake? A single missing clause that should have taken five minutes to include.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Unfortunately, Jennifer's story isn't unique. Every year, thousands of companies face devastating financial and legal consequences because of preventable severance package mistakes. These errors don't just drain bank accounts—they can trigger discrimination lawsuits, regulatory penalties, and permanent damage to your business reputation.
The stakes are particularly high for growing businesses. Unlike large corporations with extensive HR departments and legal teams, smaller companies often handle severance packages without fully understanding the complex web of federal and state requirements that govern these agreements.
Understanding Severance Package Fundamentals
A severance package represents far more than a final paycheck. It's a comprehensive agreement that can include monetary compensation, benefits continuation, job placement assistance, and legal protections for both parties.
While no federal law requires companies to offer severance pay, certain situations mandate specific benefits. The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act requires 60 days' notice for mass layoffs, and failing to provide adequate notice can result in owing affected employees up to 60 days of pay and benefits.
State laws add another layer of complexity. Some states require final paycheck delivery within 24 hours, while others allow up to the next regular payday. California mandates immediate payment upon termination, while other states have more flexible requirements.
Severance Agreement
Use our Severance Agreement Template to formalize the terms of employment separation, including severance pay, benefits continuation, waiver of claims, confidentiality, and post-termination obligations.
Trusted by 1,000+ businesses to safeguard their LLCs.
The Seven Most Expensive Severance Mistakes
Mistake 1: Inadequate Legal Documentation
The foundation of any effective severance package lies in proper documentation. Many companies rely on informal agreements or hastily drafted documents that leave critical gaps in legal protection.
Poorly written severance agreements often lack essential elements like clear consideration statements, specific payment schedules, and comprehensive release language. Without these components, the entire agreement can become legally unenforceable, leaving companies vulnerable to future litigation.
Example – The Tech Startup's $2.3 Million Error
DataFlow Technologies learned this lesson the hard way when they terminated their VP of Sales, Michael Chen, during a company restructuring. The HR manager drafted a quick severance agreement offering eight weeks of pay in exchange for Chen's agreement not to sue the company.
The problem? The agreement failed to specify exactly what claims Chen was releasing and didn't include proper consideration language. When Chen later sued for age discrimination, the court ruled the severance agreement was invalid due to inadequate documentation.
The lawsuit revealed Chen had been systematically excluded from important meetings after turning 55, and younger employees had received his responsibilities. DataFlow ultimately paid $2.3 million in damages, attorney fees, and settlement costs—money that nearly bankrupted the 40-employee company.
Mistake 2: Ignoring State-Specific Requirements
Each state has unique requirements governing severance agreements, and what works in Texas might violate California law. These differences extend beyond timing requirements to include specific language mandates, waiting periods, and disclosure obligations.
Some states require employees to have 21 days to consider severance agreements involving age discrimination claims, while others mandate seven-day revocation periods. Failing to meet these requirements can invalidate the entire agreement and expose companies to significant liability.
Pro Tip – State Compliance Checklist
Create a state-by-state compliance matrix that includes final pay requirements, waiting periods, and mandatory disclosures for each location where you have employees. Review this matrix quarterly and update it whenever you expand to new states. Consider using Legal GPS's state-specific templates to ensure compliance across all jurisdictions.
Mistake 3: Inconsistent Application Across Employees
Treating similarly situated employees differently in severance packages can trigger discrimination claims and create patterns of evidence that support class action lawsuits. Companies often make ad hoc decisions about severance amounts or terms without considering how these decisions might appear to regulators or judges.
Inconsistency becomes particularly dangerous when disparities correlate with protected characteristics like age, race, or gender. What seems like individual negotiation can quickly become evidence of systematic discrimination.
Example – The Discrimination Lawsuit That Started with Severance
Regional manufacturing company MetalWorks Industries faced a devastating age discrimination lawsuit that began with inconsistent severance packages. When the company downsized its engineering department, they offered generous severance packages to younger employees while providing minimal packages to older workers.
The disparity was stark: employees under 40 received an average of 12 weeks of severance pay, while those over 50 received just 4 weeks. When five terminated engineers compared their packages, they discovered the pattern and filed a class action lawsuit.
The case revealed that MetalWorks had consistently offered better severance terms to younger employees over a three-year period. The resulting settlement cost the company $1.8 million, plus legal fees and mandatory bias training for all managers.
Mistake 4: Failing to Include Proper Release Language
Generic release language often fails to provide adequate legal protection because it doesn't address the specific claims that matter most to your business. Companies frequently use boilerplate language that may not cover trade secret protection, customer non-solicitation, or industry-specific regulatory claims.
Effective release language must be specific, comprehensive, and legally enforceable in your jurisdiction. It should clearly identify what claims are being released and ensure the employee understands the scope of their agreement.
Mistake 5: Overlooking Benefits Continuation Requirements
COBRA compliance represents one of the most technical aspects of severance packages, and mistakes here can trigger significant penalties. Companies must provide proper COBRA notices within strict deadlines and ensure continuation coverage meets federal requirements.
Beyond COBRA, companies often overlook state-specific benefits continuation requirements, equity vesting schedules, and pension plan obligations. These oversights can result in unexpected financial liabilities months or years after the termination.
Pro Tip – COBRA Compliance Made Simple
Establish a COBRA administration timeline that triggers automatic notifications 30 days before any planned termination. Include detailed checklists for HR staff that cover notice requirements, election periods, and premium payment procedures. Consider outsourcing COBRA administration to specialized providers if you handle more than five terminations per year.
Example – The Healthcare Benefits Nightmare
Coastal Marketing Agency discovered the complexity of benefits continuation when they terminated their office manager, Sarah Williams, during a company acquisition. The HR team assumed Williams' COBRA coverage would begin automatically and failed to provide proper election notices within the required timeframe.
Six months later, Williams was diagnosed with cancer and discovered her health insurance had lapsed due to the company's administrative error. The resulting lawsuit claimed Williams had relied on promised continuation coverage and suffered significant financial harm when the coverage wasn't properly established.
The company ultimately paid $340,000 to cover Williams' medical expenses, plus attorney fees and regulatory penalties for COBRA violations. The case also triggered a Department of Labor investigation that resulted in additional fines and mandatory compliance training.
Mistake 6: Inadequate Confidentiality and Non-Compete Provisions
Post-employment restrictions require careful balancing to be legally enforceable. Overly broad non-compete clauses often get struck down by courts, while inadequate confidentiality provisions fail to protect sensitive business information.
Many companies also fail to provide adequate consideration for post-employment restrictions, particularly when these restrictions extend beyond the severance payment period. Courts increasingly scrutinize these agreements and require clear business justifications for employment restrictions.
Mistake 7: Poor Communication and Documentation
How you communicate severance terms can significantly impact legal risk and employee relations. Rushed conversations, unclear explanations, and inadequate documentation create opportunities for misunderstandings that can escalate into legal disputes.
Many companies also fail to document the business reasons for termination decisions, making it difficult to defend against discrimination claims. Proper documentation should begin long before termination discussions and continue through the final severance agreement execution.
The Real Cost of Severance Mistakes
Beyond direct litigation costs, severance mistakes can trigger cascading consequences that affect every aspect of your business. Discrimination lawsuits often attract media attention and can permanently damage your company's reputation with customers, employees, and potential hires.
Regulatory investigations frequently follow high-profile severance disputes, particularly when they involve age discrimination or benefits violations. These investigations can consume significant management time and resources, even when they don't result in formal penalties.
The average employment lawsuit costs companies $125,000 to defend, even when they ultimately prevail. Cases that go to trial can cost $300,000 or more, not including potential damage awards or settlement payments.
Severance Agreement
Use our Severance Agreement Template to formalize the terms of employment separation, including severance pay, benefits continuation, waiver of claims, confidentiality, and post-termination obligations.
Trusted by 1,000+ businesses to safeguard their LLCs.
Building a Bulletproof Severance Strategy
Effective severance planning begins long before you need to terminate any employee. Companies should establish clear policies that define eligibility criteria, payment calculations, and standard terms for different categories of employees.
Your severance policy should integrate with your overall employment practices, including performance management, documentation requirements, and legal compliance procedures. This integration ensures consistency and reduces the risk of discriminatory treatment.
Essential Documentation Requirements
Every severance package should include specific elements that protect both parties and ensure legal compliance. The agreement must clearly state the consideration being provided, specify what claims are being released, and include appropriate waiting periods where required by law.
Documentation should also address practical matters like final paycheck timing, benefits continuation procedures, and return of company property. Clear communication about these details prevents confusion and reduces the risk of post-termination disputes.
Pro Tip – Creating Standardized Severance Templates
Develop separate template agreements for different employee categories (executives, sales staff, general employees) that include state-specific provisions and industry-relevant protections. Update these templates annually and have them reviewed by employment counsel to ensure ongoing compliance with changing laws.
Example – The Manufacturing Company That Got It Right
Industrial equipment manufacturer Precision Components avoided costly mistakes by implementing a comprehensive severance program after facing their first wrongful termination lawsuit. The company developed standardized severance calculations based on tenure and position level, ensuring consistent treatment across all employees.
When Precision needed to downsize their production facility, they used their established protocols to offer identical severance packages to all affected employees in similar positions. The consistent approach prevented discrimination claims and helped maintain positive relationships with departing employees.
The company's investment in proper severance planning paid off when a departing supervisor initially threatened legal action. The comprehensive documentation and consistent treatment made it clear that the termination was part of a legitimate business restructuring, and the supervisor ultimately accepted the severance package without filing suit.
When to Seek Professional Help
Certain situations require immediate legal consultation, regardless of your company's size or internal capabilities. These red flags include terminations involving discrimination complaints, employees over 40, or situations where trade secrets or customer relationships are at stake.
Companies should also seek professional guidance when dealing with executive terminations, mass layoffs, or any situation involving employees who have expressed dissatisfaction with company policies or treatment. The cost of legal consultation is minimal compared to the potential expense of litigation.
Early legal consultation often costs $2,000 to $5,000 but can prevent lawsuits that cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Many employment attorneys offer fixed-fee severance consultations that provide clear cost predictability for budget-conscious businesses.
Protecting Your Company's Future
Preventing severance mistakes requires ongoing attention to employment law compliance and regular policy updates. Companies should conduct annual reviews of their severance policies and update them to reflect legal changes and business evolution.
Regular training for managers and HR staff ensures that everyone understands proper termination procedures and documentation requirements. This training should cover both legal compliance and practical communication strategies that preserve relationships and minimize conflict.
Consider implementing Legal GPS's comprehensive employment templates and resources to standardize your severance practices and ensure ongoing compliance. Professional-grade templates and checklists can provide the structure and protection your growing business needs while remaining cost-effective for smaller companies.
The companies that avoid costly severance mistakes aren't necessarily larger or better funded—they're simply more systematic about planning and compliance. With proper preparation and the right resources, any company can build effective severance practices that protect both the business and departing employees while minimizing legal risk and maintaining positive workplace relationships.
Legal GPS Pro
Protect your business with our complete legal subscription service, designed by top startup attorneys.
- ✅ Complete Legal Toolkit
- ✅ 100+ Editable Contracts
- ✅ Affordable Legal Guidance
- ✅ Custom Legal Status Report
Popular
|
Premium Template
Single-use Template |
Legal GPS Pro
Unlimited Access, Best Value |
|
|
| Choose Template | Learn More |
| Trusted by 1000+ businesses | |
How to Stop Employees From Stealing Your Clients (Legally)
You built your business one client relationship at a time. You invested in training employees, developing systems, and creating value that clients...
Mastering the Hiring Process: A Comprehensive Guide for Startups
For any business, human resources are a key element for success, but for startups, figuring out the hiring process can be tricky. Between forms to...